Our Menu

An Offer You Can’t Refuse

  • Authentic Italian favorites and American classics served Calabash-style
Warning! Viewing this menu may lead to a permanent craving. Proceed with caution.
Inspect The Evidence

The Full Lineup

Time to make a sangwheech!
Sandwiches
Sandwiches You Can’t Erase from Your Memory.
Pizza
In Pizza We Crust
Hand-Tossed and Strictly Confidential.
Sweet Treats
Leave the Gun, Take the Cannoli
Desserts Worth Going to the Mat For.

Our Sacred Oath

We’re committed to using only the freshest and highest quality ingredients. To us, food isn't just business—it’s personal. From traditional Italian recipes passed down by our grandparents to the classic American hot dogs and cheesesteaks we grew up on, everything is made with the kind of care you’d find in Grandma’s kitchen.

Signature Sandwiches

Codfish Sandwich
Maryland Crabcake Sandwich
Ham Cheese On Rye
Cheese Steak Sandwich
Meatball Parm
Codfish Sandwich
View all menu

Building the Legacy

The Family is looking toward the horizon.
The Codfather isn't just a sandwich shop; it’s a tradition we’ve planted firmly in the heart of Calabash. We believe in doing things the right way—with respect for the ingredients and a commitment to the neighborhood that welcomed us in.
Future Locations Heading Your Way: Southport and Wrightsville Beach

Testimonials

My pizza review. So being from NJ we are always looking for great pizza here in the South. Look no further, we have found it at the Codfather sandwich shop, Calabash. The crust and the cheese are perfect and the sauce delicious. Stop in and try it, you will not be disappointed!
★★★★★
 ~ Lisa
I had the Codfathers crumb cake and it was delicious. The cake was moist and the crumb’s plentiful. Can’t wait to have it again. 
★★★★★
 ~ Mike G

"Goodnight, Miss Calabash... wherever you are."

We're Hiring
The Family is expanding and we’re looking for the best in the business. Submit your resume today and join the crew.
Phone : 910-579-7001
When the Boss says we're open
Monday - Saturday10:00 AM - 7:00 PM

Our Calabash Location

© Copyright 2026 The Codfather Sandwich Shop LLC. All rights reserved.